Suggestion and a great solution

[mateop08]

First of all, what amazing work you've done. I think if this app improves, it could be better than sightreadingfactory or any sightreading generator.

What happens is that this app becomes usefull if you are keyboard player, because of the midi option. I am a guitar player and I use this app for training my sight reading, but I can't use the scroll mode because I can't connect my guitar as a midi controller, I have to use the wait mode, and click in random every time I want a new sightreading exercise, this becomes a little annoying and impractical. Then any other musican who can't conect their instrument to the computer will get the same problem, and wouldn't get the most of this app. So, I suggest a solution for this issue. A nice idea is that the scroll mode has the option to select if you want that the notes that are scrolling will be verified or not by the software, in order to any other musician could use the scroll mode without the trouble that the scroll mode stop the exercise, they just can't "say" to the computer that they are playing the right note just because they are not conected. I think this is a good solution, and this will expand the amount of musician who can use this incredible app.

Greetings.

[mredivo]

This comment applies particularly to acoustic-only instruments.

The player has to be their own judge of whether they got it right. The notes just keep coming, which is actually what happens in ensemble playing anyway.

[mateop08]

You play violin right, I just read it in the other post. You're right, the player has to be his own judge. But tell me how do you conect you're violin as a midi controller? It's the same problem that I have with my guitar, I think that for not being a keyboard player, it is a risk that we should assume. And that's why I suggested that.

A nice idea is that the scroll mode has the option to select if you want that the notes that are scrolling will be verified or not by the software, in order to any other musician could use the scroll mode without the trouble that the scroll mode stop the exercise

I'm waiting that leafo tell us what he thinks.