collectingBodyPart

[zedomel]

Field	Value
GUID
Rebipp Class	rebipp:Interaction
Label	collectingBodyPart
Definition	The animal body part (e.g. organ) used to access the floral resources.
Comments
Examples	glossa, bill, tongue, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/HAO_0000376
Controlled vocabulary	Hymenoptera Anatomy Ontology Portal
Darwin Core Class	Event
Cardinality	One to one
Reference Protocol

[zedomel]

collectingBodyPart term definition:

The animal body part used to access the floral resources

collectingBodyPartLength definition:

The length in millimeters of the body part used to access the floral resource

@pzermoglio:

not sure used to access the floral resources is specific enough.

[fonturbel]

The term name is a little bit confusing

[zedomel]

@fonturbel do you have any suggestion?

[carmensspires]

collectingBodyPart by definition refers only to pollen?

[fonturbel]

@fonturbel do you have any suggestion?

Something more general: mouth parts, dorsal area, abdomen, or limbs for example...

[terezagiannini]

I agree with the idea "Something more general: mouth parts, dorsal area, abdomen, or limbs for example.."
I think there will be little information to inform this field in millimeters

[pietrokiyoshi]

I agree with @fonturbel to add something more general. If we consider other resources than nectar (pollen, oil) collection is done with the limbs (mostly) and not mouth parts, for example.

[RafaelCBorges]

After thinking for some time on the usability of this term, I could not find a good example of the interest in the length of pollen collecting body part structures.
In the case of bees it would be mouth parts and legs, but our interest for this field, I believe, sets on the tongue length (which is mostly used for collecting nectar). When thinking of hummingbirds the interest would be on the beak length, which is also the nectar collecting structure. And so on when thinking about bats, butterflies, etc.
Thus, I suggest changing the name of this term to NectarCollectingBodyPart, which would be more specific in providing the data.
@fonturbel and @carmensspires, mouth parts, dorsal area, abdomen, or limbs and the structures used to collect pollen are provided in the field animalPlaceOfContact, where a list of all animal body parts in contact to the flower are provided. I think here we can be more specific.
@terezagiannini, I think millimetres is a good unit for the field NectarCollectingBodyPartLength, as it encompass the smallest (insects), and can be easily converted for inputs from vertebrate taxa (which will be in many many millimetres).
@pietrokiyoshi, isn't that information already provided in the animalPlaceOfContact field?

[zedomel]

Hi people,

Since the floral resources can be anything like nectar, oil, pollen, etc. and an animal can collect multiple resources at same time I don't see how this term can be used to capture all this body parts. If we used a list of body parts then the term colectingBodyPartLength does not make sense, because we can not have a list of body parts length due the ordering problem.

@RafaelCBorges the term animalPlaceOfContact can be used to capture structures that the animal is using to collecting pollen, but the term's definition does not explicit says that these body parts are used to collecting. It does say that these body parts contacts the flower and just it. If this information if sufficient, then we can go that way.

Following the discussion, my suggestion is to change the term label and definition to:
Label: nectarCollectingBodyPart
Definition: The animal body part used to collect nectar from the plant nectaries
Comments: The plant nectaries can be floral or extrafloral nectaries

Does it makes sense?

[RafaelCBorges]

@zedomel, could the description of animalPlaceOfContact be updated to also include structures used for collecting? Just to include this information.
Anyway, I believe the information about the body parts used for collecting are already included in that definition, as they must be in contact for collecting.
I think the new term label and definition is good.