README.md

Alternatives to if

This is a collection of alternatives to using if and other conditional block statements in plain Javascript without module or library dependencies.

Some reasons to consider alternatives:

• boost immutability: because const is scope-level, it is unusable in functions using if except within the blocks -- for assignment, let or var are the only options, which are mutable
• quality of code life: if is block statement that has a tendency to beget nesting block statements ad infinitum, and become progressively harder to read as they are added to
• avoid refactoring later: many ifs can usually indicate you really need to break your functions down further, and that your function is doing too much at once
• often it should really just be a function: because it is a block-level element, the block can easily grow into something that clearly should be a function, or even many functions
• control side-effects: switch statements can easily "leak" when missing a break statement, and create "branches" of code without braces, hiding these branches somewhat
• testability: each if creates a logical branch that cannot be independantly tested
• functional: if functional programming is something you want to do more of, you'll generally want less if and let
• be safer with type: when you convert an if into a function, you can test for types in TypeScript and Flow

Caveat

The following examples may or may not adhere to a functional programming style, but can be used as a stepping stone towards more functional code. I tend to prefer functional, but it can be a huge leap to go straight to pure functional.

Kinds of ifs

Each example is a very basic form of a common conditional pattern. These suggestions are meant to give you some ideas of alternatives.

Some examples, such as the "incongruent if/else" examples could be considered antipatterns and are themselves likely to be considered by most as poorly-formed if statements.

Basic if

let y;
if (x === 1) {
    y = 2;
}

Alternatives

Ternary assignment

Basic, returns y as false for default.

// ternary with false default
const y = x === 1 ? 2 : false;

Functional ternary

Similar, but has a reusable function that can be memoized.

// functional ternary
const checkX = x => (x === 1 ? 2 : false);
const y = checkX(x);

if/else

let y;
if (x === 1) {
    y = 2;
} else {
    y = 1;
}

Alternatives

Ternary assignment

Very basic, readable. Allows y to be a const.

// ternary assignment
const y = x === 1 ? 2 : 1;

Functional ternary

Very similar, but reusable and memoizable.

// functional ternary
const checkX = x => (x === 1 ? 2 : 1);
const y = checkX(x);

if/else/else if

let y;
if (x === 1) {
    y = 2;
} else if (x === 2) {
    y = 17.3;
} else {
    y = 1;
}

or, switch/case/break

switch (x) {
    case 1:
        y = 2;
        break;
    case 2:
        y = 17.3;
        break;
    default:
        y = 1;
}

Alternatives

Object key-value pairs

Use an object to store values as key-value pairs.

// key-value pair list with default
const vals = {
    1: 2,
    2: 17.3,
    default: 1
};
const y = x in vals ? vals[x] : vals.default;

Object key-value pairs with default symbol

Very similar, and prevents namespace collisions: use a symbol for your default value key. (The example above with default key would likely misbehave if x ever had a value called 'default'.)

// key-value pair list with symbol
// this avoids namespace collision in key names
// note that `$$` is merely a naming style suggestion for Symbols, it is not a requirement at all
const $$defaultSymbol = Symbol();
const vals = {
    1: 2,
    2: 17.3,
    [$$defaultSymbol]: 1
};
const y = x in vals ? vals[x] : vals[$$defaultSymbol];

Array-based value list

Or, use an array to store the values. Works only if dealing with low numbers.

// value list accessed by index
const vals = [null, 2, 17.3];
const y = vals[x] || 1;

Constant function expression getter

Use a getter inside a constant function expression as a means of looking up a key-value pair. Allows for memoization, though uses the dreaded this keyword...

// getter
const vals = x => ({
    1: 2,
    2: 17.3,
    get value() {
        return this[x] || 1;
    }
});
const y = vals(x).value;

Conditionals table

Constant function expression returning a lookup table: zeroth index is the condition, first index is the result.

// conditionals table
const condTable = x => [
    [x === 1, 2],
    [x === 2, 17.3],
    [true, 1]
];
const y = condTable(x)
    .find(a => (a[0] ? a[1] : false))
    .pop();

Incongruent if/else if conditions

let y;
if (x === 1) {
    y = 2;
} else if (x === 2) {
    y = 17.3;
} else if (z === 4) {
    y = 19.2;
{ else if (w === 'something') {
    y = 22;
} else {
    y = 1;
}

Alternatives

Conditionals table

Another constant function expression returning a lookup table, this time taking an array as a parameter. The array param allows for memoization of the table.

// conditionals table with array param
// array-based param allows for memoization if need be
const condTable = ([x, z, w]) => [
    [x === 1, 2],
    [x === 2, 17.3],
    [z === 4, 19.2],
    [w === 'something', 22],
    [true, 1]
];
const y = condTable([x, z, w])
    .find(a => (a[0] ? a[1] : false))
    .pop();

Incongruent if/else if results

What if not just the conditions are mixed, but the results too?

let y;
let j;
if (x === 1) {
    y = 2;
} else if (x === 2) {
    y = 17.3;
} else if (z === 4) {
    y = 19.2;
{ else if (w === 'something') {
    y = 22;
{ else if (w === 'something else') {
    j = 5;
} else {
    y = 1;
}

Alternatives

Conditional functions table

Similar to conditionals table, use the table to execute functions rather than assign value.

// results are functions, pass everything into params that might be needed
let y, j;
const setY = v => y = v;
const setJ = v => j = v;
const condTable = ([x, z, w]) => [
    [x === 1, setY, 2],
    [x === 2, setY, 17.3],
    [z === 4, setY, 19.2],
    [w === 'something', setY, 22],
    [w === 'something else', setJ, 5],
    [true, setY, 1]
];

condTable([x, z, w])
    .find(a => (a[0] ? a[1](a[2]) : false));

Nested if

let y, z;
if (x === 1) {
    y = 2;
    if (w > 4) {
        z = 1;
    }
} else {
    y = 1;
    if (w < 4) {
        z = 2;
    }
}

Alternatives

Functional flattening

Take each layer and transpose each if to a function, or assignment.

const fn1 = () => {
    y = 2;
    z = w > 4 ? 1 : z;
};

const fn2 = () => {
    y = 1;
    z = w < 4 ? 2 : z;
};

const assignVals = x =>
    x === 1
        ? fn1()
        : fn2();