Fix MAU reaping where reserved users are specified. (matrix-org#6168)

changelog.d/6168.bugfix

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Fix monthly active user reaping where reserved users are specified.

synapse/app/homeserver.py

@@ -605,13 +605,13 @@ def reap_monthly_active_users():
     @defer.inlineCallbacks
     def generate_monthly_active_users():
         current_mau_count = 0
-        reserved_count = 0
+        reserved_users = ()
         store = hs.get_datastore()
         if hs.config.limit_usage_by_mau or hs.config.mau_stats_only:
             current_mau_count = yield store.get_monthly_active_count()
-            reserved_count = yield store.get_registered_reserved_users_count()
+            reserved_users = yield store.get_registered_reserved_users()
         current_mau_gauge.set(float(current_mau_count))
-        registered_reserved_users_mau_gauge.set(float(reserved_count))
+        registered_reserved_users_mau_gauge.set(float(len(reserved_users)))
         max_mau_gauge.set(float(hs.config.max_mau_value))
 
     def start_generate_monthly_active_users():

synapse/storage/monthly_active_users.py

@@ -32,7 +32,6 @@ def __init__(self, dbconn, hs):
         super(MonthlyActiveUsersStore, self).__init__(None, hs)
         self._clock = hs.get_clock()
         self.hs = hs
-        self.reserved_users = ()
         # Do not add more reserved users than the total allowable number
         self._new_transaction(
             dbconn,
@@ -51,7 +50,6 @@ def _initialise_reserved_users(self, txn, threepids):
             txn (cursor):
             threepids (list[dict]): List of threepid dicts to reserve
         """
-        reserved_user_list = []
 
         for tp in threepids:
             user_id = self.get_user_id_by_threepid_txn(txn, tp["medium"], tp["address"])
@@ -60,10 +58,8 @@ def _initialise_reserved_users(self, txn, threepids):
                 is_support = self.is_support_user_txn(txn, user_id)
                 if not is_support:
                     self.upsert_monthly_active_user_txn(txn, user_id)
-                    reserved_user_list.append(user_id)
             else:
                 logger.warning("mau limit reserved threepid %s not found in db" % tp)
-        self.reserved_users = tuple(reserved_user_list)
 
     @defer.inlineCallbacks
     def reap_monthly_active_users(self):
@@ -74,29 +70,31 @@ def reap_monthly_active_users(self):
             Deferred[]
         """
 
-        def _reap_users(txn):
-            # Purge stale users
+        def _reap_users(txn, reserved_users):
+            """
+            Args:
+                reserved_users (tuple): reserved users to preserve
+            """
 
             thirty_days_ago = int(self._clock.time_msec()) - (1000 * 60 * 60 * 24 * 30)
             query_args = [thirty_days_ago]
             base_sql = "DELETE FROM monthly_active_users WHERE timestamp < ?"
 
             # Need if/else since 'AND user_id NOT IN ({})' fails on Postgres
             # when len(reserved_users) == 0. Works fine on sqlite.
-            if len(self.reserved_users) > 0:
+            if len(reserved_users) > 0:
                 # questionmarks is a hack to overcome sqlite not supporting
                 # tuples in 'WHERE IN %s'
-                questionmarks = "?" * len(self.reserved_users)
+                question_marks = ",".join("?" * len(reserved_users))
 
-                query_args.extend(self.reserved_users)
-                sql = base_sql + """ AND user_id NOT IN ({})""".format(
-                    ",".join(questionmarks)
-                )
+                query_args.extend(reserved_users)
+                sql = base_sql + " AND user_id NOT IN ({})".format(question_marks)
             else:
                 sql = base_sql
 
             txn.execute(sql, query_args)
 
+            max_mau_value = self.hs.config.max_mau_value
             if self.hs.config.limit_usage_by_mau:
                 # If MAU user count still exceeds the MAU threshold, then delete on
                 # a least recently active basis.
@@ -106,31 +104,52 @@ def _reap_users(txn):
                 # While Postgres does not require 'LIMIT', but also does not support
                 # negative LIMIT values. So there is no way to write it that both can
                 # support
-                safe_guard = self.hs.config.max_mau_value - len(self.reserved_users)
-                # Must be greater than zero for postgres
-                safe_guard = safe_guard if safe_guard > 0 else 0
-                query_args = [safe_guard]
-
-                base_sql = """
-                    DELETE FROM monthly_active_users
-                    WHERE user_id NOT IN (
-                        SELECT user_id FROM monthly_active_users
-                        ORDER BY timestamp DESC
-                        LIMIT ?
+                if len(reserved_users) == 0:
+                    sql = """
+                        DELETE FROM monthly_active_users
+                        WHERE user_id NOT IN (
+                            SELECT user_id FROM monthly_active_users
+                            ORDER BY timestamp DESC
+                            LIMIT ?
                         )
-                    """
+                        """
+                    txn.execute(sql, (max_mau_value,))
                 # Need if/else since 'AND user_id NOT IN ({})' fails on Postgres
                 # when len(reserved_users) == 0. Works fine on sqlite.
-                if len(self.reserved_users) > 0:
-                    query_args.extend(self.reserved_users)
-                    sql = base_sql + """ AND user_id NOT IN ({})""".format(
-                        ",".join(questionmarks)
-                    )
                 else:
-                    sql = base_sql
-                txn.execute(sql, query_args)
+                    # Must be >= 0 for postgres
+                    num_of_non_reserved_users_to_remove = max(
+                        max_mau_value - len(reserved_users), 0
+                    )
+
+                    # It is important to filter reserved users twice to guard
+                    # against the case where the reserved user is present in the
+                    # SELECT, meaning that a legitmate mau is deleted.
+                    sql = """
+                        DELETE FROM monthly_active_users
+                        WHERE user_id NOT IN (
+                            SELECT user_id FROM monthly_active_users
+                            WHERE user_id NOT IN ({})
+                            ORDER BY timestamp DESC
+                            LIMIT ?
+                        )
+                        AND user_id NOT IN ({})
+                    """.format(
+                        question_marks, question_marks
+                    )
+
+                    query_args = [
+                        *reserved_users,
+                        num_of_non_reserved_users_to_remove,
+                        *reserved_users,
+                    ]
 
-        yield self.runInteraction("reap_monthly_active_users", _reap_users)
+                    txn.execute(sql, query_args)
+
+        reserved_users = yield self.get_registered_reserved_users()
+        yield self.runInteraction(
+            "reap_monthly_active_users", _reap_users, reserved_users
+        )
         # It seems poor to invalidate the whole cache, Postgres supports
         # 'Returning' which would allow me to invalidate only the
         # specific users, but sqlite has no way to do this and instead
@@ -159,21 +178,25 @@ def _count_users(txn):
         return self.runInteraction("count_users", _count_users)
 
     @defer.inlineCallbacks
-    def get_registered_reserved_users_count(self):
-        """Of the reserved threepids defined in config, how many are associated
+    def get_registered_reserved_users(self):
+        """Of the reserved threepids defined in config, which are associated
         with registered users?
 
         Returns:
-            Defered[int]: Number of real reserved users
+            Defered[list]: Real reserved users
         """
-        count = 0
-        for tp in self.hs.config.mau_limits_reserved_threepids:
+        users = []
+
+        for tp in self.hs.config.mau_limits_reserved_threepids[
+            : self.hs.config.max_mau_value
+        ]:
             user_id = yield self.hs.get_datastore().get_user_id_by_threepid(
                 tp["medium"], tp["address"]
             )
             if user_id:
-                count = count + 1
-        return count
+                users.append(user_id)
+
+        return users
 
     @defer.inlineCallbacks
     def upsert_monthly_active_user(self, user_id):

tests/storage/test_monthly_active_users.py

@@ -50,6 +50,7 @@ def test_initialise_reserved_users(self):
             {"medium": "email", "address": user2_email},
             {"medium": "email", "address": user3_email},
         ]
+        self.hs.config.mau_limits_reserved_threepids = threepids
         # -1 because user3 is a support user and does not count
         user_num = len(threepids) - 1
 
@@ -84,6 +85,7 @@ def test_initialise_reserved_users(self):
         self.hs.config.max_mau_value = 0
 
         self.reactor.advance(FORTY_DAYS)
+        self.hs.config.max_mau_value = 5
 
         self.store.reap_monthly_active_users()
         self.pump()
@@ -147,9 +149,7 @@ def test_reap_monthly_active_users(self):
         self.store.reap_monthly_active_users()
         self.pump()
         count = self.store.get_monthly_active_count()
-        self.assertEquals(
-            self.get_success(count), initial_users - self.hs.config.max_mau_value
-        )
+        self.assertEquals(self.get_success(count), self.hs.config.max_mau_value)
 
         self.reactor.advance(FORTY_DAYS)
         self.store.reap_monthly_active_users()
@@ -158,6 +158,44 @@ def test_reap_monthly_active_users(self):
         count = self.store.get_monthly_active_count()
         self.assertEquals(self.get_success(count), 0)
 
+    def test_reap_monthly_active_users_reserved_users(self):
+        """ Tests that reaping correctly handles reaping where reserved users are
+        present"""
+
+        self.hs.config.max_mau_value = 5
+        initial_users = 5
+        reserved_user_number = initial_users - 1
+        threepids = []
+        for i in range(initial_users):
+            user = "@user%d:server" % i
+            email = "user%[email protected]" % i
+            self.get_success(self.store.upsert_monthly_active_user(user))
+            threepids.append({"medium": "email", "address": email})
+            # Need to ensure that the most recent entries in the
+            # monthly_active_users table are reserved
+            now = int(self.hs.get_clock().time_msec())
+            if i != 0:
+                self.get_success(
+                    self.store.register_user(user_id=user, password_hash=None)
+                )
+                self.get_success(
+                    self.store.user_add_threepid(user, "email", email, now, now)
+                )
+
+        self.hs.config.mau_limits_reserved_threepids = threepids
+        self.store.runInteraction(
+            "initialise", self.store._initialise_reserved_users, threepids
+        )
+        count = self.store.get_monthly_active_count()
+        self.assertTrue(self.get_success(count), initial_users)
+
+        users = self.store.get_registered_reserved_users()
+        self.assertEquals(len(self.get_success(users)), reserved_user_number)
+
+        self.get_success(self.store.reap_monthly_active_users())
+        count = self.store.get_monthly_active_count()
+        self.assertEquals(self.get_success(count), self.hs.config.max_mau_value)
+
     def test_populate_monthly_users_is_guest(self):
         # Test that guest users are not added to mau list
         user_id = "@user_id:host"
@@ -192,12 +230,13 @@ def test_populate_monthly_users_should_not_update(self):
 
     def test_get_reserved_real_user_account(self):
         # Test no reserved users, or reserved threepids
-        count = self.store.get_registered_reserved_users_count()
-        self.assertEquals(self.get_success(count), 0)
+        users = self.get_success(self.store.get_registered_reserved_users())
+        self.assertEquals(len(users), 0)
         # Test reserved users but no registered users
 
         user1 = "@user1:example.com"
         user2 = "@user2:example.com"
+
         user1_email = "[email protected]"
         user2_email = "[email protected]"
         threepids = [
@@ -210,8 +249,8 @@ def test_get_reserved_real_user_account(self):
         )
 
         self.pump()
-        count = self.store.get_registered_reserved_users_count()
-        self.assertEquals(self.get_success(count), 0)
+        users = self.get_success(self.store.get_registered_reserved_users())
+        self.assertEquals(len(users), 0)
 
         # Test reserved registed users
         self.store.register_user(user_id=user1, password_hash=None)
@@ -221,8 +260,9 @@ def test_get_reserved_real_user_account(self):
         now = int(self.hs.get_clock().time_msec())
         self.store.user_add_threepid(user1, "email", user1_email, now, now)
         self.store.user_add_threepid(user2, "email", user2_email, now, now)
-        count = self.store.get_registered_reserved_users_count()
-        self.assertEquals(self.get_success(count), len(threepids))
+
+        users = self.get_success(self.store.get_registered_reserved_users())
+        self.assertEquals(len(users), len(threepids))
 
     def test_support_user_not_add_to_mau_limits(self):
         support_user_id = "@support:test"