Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
Remove maskna API from ndarray, and all (and only) the code supportin…
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
…g it

The original masked-NA-NEP branch contained a large number of changes
in addition to the core NA support. For example:
 - ufunc.__call__ support for where= argument
 - nditer support for arbitrary masks (in support of where=)
 - ufunc.reduce support for simultaneous reduction over multiple axes
 - a new "array assignment API"
 - ndarray.diagonal() returning a view in all cases
 - bug-fixes in __array_priority__ handling
 - datetime test changes
etc. There's no consensus yet on what should be done with the
maskna-related part of this branch, but the rest is generally useful
and uncontroversial, so the goal of this branch is to identify exactly
which code changes are involved in maskna support.

The basic strategy used to create this patch was:
 - Remove the new masking-related fields from ndarray, so no arrays
   are masked
 - Go through and remove all the code that this makes
   dead/inaccessible/irrelevant, in a largely mechanical fashion. So
   for example, if I saw 'if (PyArray_HASMASK(a)) { ... }' then that
   whole block was obviously just dead code if no arrays have masks,
   and I removed it. Likewise for function arguments like skipna that
   are useless if there aren't any NAs to skip.

This changed the signature of a number of functions that were newly
exposed in the numpy public API. I've removed all such functions from
the public API, since releasing them with the NA-less signature in 1.7
would create pointless compatibility hassles later if and when we add
back the NA-related functionality. Most such functions are removed by
this commit; the exception is PyArray_ReduceWrapper, which requires
more extensive surgery, and will be handled in followup commits.

I also removed the new ndarray.setasflat method. Reason: a comment
noted that the only reason this was added was to allow easier testing
of one branch of PyArray_CopyAsFlat. That branch is now the main
branch, so that isn't an issue. Nonetheless this function is arguably
useful, so perhaps it should have remained, but I judged that since
numpy's API is already hairier than we would like, it's not a good
idea to add extra hair "just in case". (Also AFAICT the test for this
method in test_maskna was actually incorrect, as noted here:
   https://github.com/njsmith/numpyNEP/blob/master/numpyNEP.py
so I'm not confident that it ever worked in master, though I haven't
had a chance to follow-up on this.)

I also removed numpy.count_reduce_items, since without skipna it
became trivial.

I believe that these are the only exceptions to the "remove dead code"
strategy.
  • Loading branch information
njsmith committed Jun 16, 2012
1 parent 1b6582d commit b272bc6
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Showing 87 changed files with 789 additions and 11,563 deletions.
306 changes: 0 additions & 306 deletions doc/source/reference/arrays.maskna.rst

This file was deleted.

1 change: 0 additions & 1 deletion doc/source/reference/arrays.rst
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -44,7 +44,6 @@ of also more complicated arrangements of data.
arrays.indexing
arrays.nditer
arrays.classes
arrays.maskna
maskedarray
arrays.interface
arrays.datetime
Loading

0 comments on commit b272bc6

Please sign in to comment.